Migration by Race and Income in Northern California, 2015

Migration by Race and Income in Northern California, 2015

The California Housing Partnership and Urban Displacement Project received a one-year grant from The San Francisco Foundation to document the mobility patterns for low-income people of color at the neighborhood level in Alameda, Contra Costa and San Francisco counties.  Our reports and maps provide evidence that low-income people of color in the Bay Area suffer the most as housing prices rise, and displacement pressures push them into higher poverty, lower-resource neighborhoods where the odds are stacked against them.  

Migration Map

These maps show people who moved in 2015 for the 9-County Bay Area Region. This data comes from the ACS 1-year Public Use Microdata Sample (PUMS) for 2015. To use the map, start by clicking on the county of origin, then select the race and income group of interest. The map will show where movers from this county went (within Northern California), as well as provide data on people who left the region and state.

Key Findings

  • Between 2000 and 2015, as housing prices rose, the City of Richmond, the Bayview in San Francisco, and flatlands areas of Oakland and Berkeley lost thousands of low-income black households. Increases in low-income black households during the same period were concentrated in cities and neighborhoods with lower housing prices and fewer resources —such as Antioch and Pittsburg in East Contra Costa County, as well parts of Hayward and the unincorporated communities of Ashland and Cherryland in Alameda County.  
  • Large increases in the number of low-income people of color living in areas that became newly segregated and high-poverty between 2000 and 2015 are evidence that rising housing costs and migration patterns have contributed to new concentrations of segregation and poverty in the region.
  • Low-income households of color were much more vulnerable than low-income white households to the impact of rapid increases in housing prices. In the Bay Area, a 30% tract-level increase in median rent paid between 2000 and 2015 was associated with a 21% decrease in low-income households of color but was not associated with a change in low-income white households.
  • Low-income households who made any kind of move in 2015—whether they stayed within their county of origin or left it—ended up paying a higher share of their income on rent than those who did not move, a clear indicator of the high cost of displacement.
  • Upon moving, a significant share of low-income people of all races not only left their county of origin but the region altogether. For example, 40 percent of low-income black households in Alameda County who moved in 2015 left the Bay Area, another indication of regional displacement pressures.